Clinch wrote:Napoleonics here too
[N]Sloop wrote:So, if the ranks are by clans and the statistics by teams then our lesser members should not join. If individual stats are recorded as well then I will not ally myself with anyone but the best. If you can not help me and bring my rank higher then do not ask me to fight with you. Why climb a ladder if not to reach the top?
Better not to have been born than to live without glory.
............................................Napoleon Bonaparte
Sloop wrote:Ladders can be ugly. Imagine the arguments in the community over a ladder due to drops, cheats, etc. We can hardly have a simple tourney without overwhelming drama and endless debate. In fact we can hardly have a friendly game without these argumentative aspects in our community. A ladder will segregate games into ladder or non-ladder games. If successful a large segment of the community or even the majority of players will predominately play ladder games. Higher ranked players will refuse games to protect their stats while lower ranked payers will hound the best players for a shot up the ladder. Those not on the ladder will be divided into a separate type of group, living outside the popularity as well as the frustration and politics of a ladder. Tournaments, ladders and ranking systems, change the dynamic of the hobby from a contest of Gentlemen into a schoolgirls' cat fight. We all fight for victory and most of us with honor. But we also fight for the glory of the battle during the battle. The excitement of the contest while it is raging. Other than these motivators, the idea of profit and loss, recorded publicly on a record, will loom as the primary goal of ladder participants.
If I were to join the ladder it would be to reach the top. The level of victory and the history of the battle will no longer be significant. Only another reported victory will matter. A good fight will be irrelevant. A Gentleman's duel, a relaxing contest or a casual game will no longer exist. If you want a game with me then join the ladder as I can't waste my time with non-profit games. The less experience you have the better because I will use you to pad my stats. Historical simulation, the nostalgic feel of a Gentleman's community, and much of the honor will be lost. All this for a small payment of prestige and popularity. I will use all tools at my disposal and have no mercy to reach #1. Except for the minimal confines of honor, I will kill, slaughter, and destroy anyone and everyone who stands in my way... IF I were to join the ladder.
Return to Napoleonic Total War 3
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests